April, 2026
BLOG 158
ROUND 2
“Ironically, psychopathology is one of the signs of the larger imagination of the psyche, or soul. If we had no soul, that is, had no organ of meaning, our adaptations would be our reality. But the soul protests and registers its protest through our body, our troubling dreams, our affective invasions, such as depression or our addictive, anesthetizing self-treatment.“
(James Hollis Living an Examined Life)
The above passage reminds me that I am on an evolutionary or soul journey. And that some of the ways my body, emotions or mind “act out” are not to be suppressed or ignored, or even modified to better keep me in line, but rather to be taken as the soul’s protest against not living up to my potential. That is, the potential to be a fully evolved, enlightened human being.
James Hollis suggests that the “soul” is synonymous with our “organ of meaning”. Moreover, the “adaptations” he writes about are most likely an individual’s attempts to tick all the boxes, to survive in the world and in one’s own eyes, according to a script that has been dictated, largely by external influences — institutions, authority figures, media, etc. and only tweaked by the individual’s particular circumstances. In other words, most of us have “drunk the Kool Aid” from a very young age.
I find it reassuring and motivating to consider the part of me that asks questions, studies, chants and reflects on life events to be aligned with my soul, the aspect that has never been content with pat answers, or satisfied with the status quo. But I’d be guilty of hypocrisy if I said it didn’t matter to me whether I was liked and accepted, appreciated, even admired and respected by the people around me. We are, after all, social animals, and fear of rejection by our particular tribe is a dominant factor directing our lives.
Like a protective parent, a part of me monitors what I think or feel, do or say to ensure my behavior aligns with that of the “tribe”, or, as Hillevi Ruumet puts it, the social matrix into which I was born. To see my discomfort with or suspicions re: the status quo as protests of my soul brings up some interesting questions.
Hollis frames his questions as follows:
“While most of modern psychiatry and psychotherapy prefer to work around these protests and thereby drive the internal conflict deeper, the psychodynamic understanding of symptoms, dreams, and behavioral patterns is rather to ask: Why have you come? What is it you are protesting? What is the desire of the soul (as opposed to the desires of my environment, my complexes, my history)? These questions do not bury the issue, try to bypass it, or medicate it into numbness, but rather approach the soul with dignity and ask, as we might of any stranger who knocks unbidden at our door, “Why have you come? What do you want? How might we converse?”
And these, my friends, are the six million dollar questions. Actually, the first of many. Should we choose to ask them, we usher in what Hollis calls the second half of the journey:
“The second half of life is not a chronological moment but a psychological moment that some people, however old, however accomplished, however self-satisfied in life, never reach. The second half of life occurs when people, for whatever reason — death of partner, end of marriage, illness, retirement, whatever — are obliged to radically consider who they are apart from their history, their roles, and their commitments.”
I suspect the second half of my life began in my mid-thirties, first with the loss of a loved one, the serious illness of a child, followed by the loss of our income, our home, and a break from the security and certainty of life as I’d known it. Looking back I can see a grand design in all that happened. Two major moves and the acquaintance of a spiritual seeker set me on a different trajectory. One I am still trying to honour with what T.S. Eliot calls just enough “light to secure the next foothold”. The light cast by Hollis and a host of teachers who have gone this way before me.
Now how to get off this heavy jag with some levity. How about I promise to go lighter next week? Tomorrow is Monday, and this is all I’ve got.
